The Difference Between American & Italian Pizza

Pizza is one of the most popular dishes all around the world. It belongs to the Italian cuisine (specifically to the traditional Neapolitan one) and starting from Italy, it gained great success all around the world. However pizza is not only a popular dish: it is also one of the most reinterpreted recipes, so that it is made in very different ways in every country of the world. Pizza can be served as a main dish or it can be sold in slices as street food variants you can eat as a fast meal. In addition, there are actually two big interpretations of pizza recipes: the traditional Italian one and the American one.

The most popular type of pizza you can find in the world has been invented by American people. Outside Italy you can find several American food chains specialized in serving this dish: Pizza Hut and Domino’s Pizza are two of the most popular ones. Anyway the type of pizza produced by these and other chains is clearly different from the original you can eat in Italy. As I am an Italian person who sometimes travels abroad, I have the opportunity to compare pizza I eat in my country with the one I can usually find in an American food chain. The big difference starts from the food concept people have about this dish: in Italy pizza tends to be a relatively light dish (the most popular edition in Italy is the so called pizza margherita, which is topped with tomato and mozzarella cheese), so that a person usually eats one entire pizza for launch or for dinner.

See also: the Italian Pizza With Basil Pesto & Cheese (mozzarella or stracchino)

Pizza in Italy is not considered as junk food: a pizza a week is included in most diet programs and it is definitely a complete meal everyone can enjoy without worrying so much about health. Instead the most popular American version of this dish is the pepperoni pizza (topped with a type of salami) and, in general, American people love to add several ingredients to their pizzas, so that they tend to customize them in very different ways. Sometimes you can also find variations in the crust: a popular Pizza Hut product, for example, is bordered by cheesy bites (instead of the traditional crust).

The American pizza recipes are obviously much more fat than the Italian ones, that’s why pizza is generally considered as junk food in most parts of the world, but let’s debunk a myth: the original Italian recipe is not dangerous for your silhouette, instead it is a very healthy solution you can eat every week without problems.

Many American pizzas are topped with various sauces and spices. In general, they tend to be more complex and caloric than an Italian version, so that an entire pizza is divided among different people: it is a fast food dish. Also in Italy we have various types of toppings, but they are lighter than the American ones. Talking about the cooking, pizza in Italy is traditional hand-cooked and baked into wood ovens, while American chains use industrial ingredients, kneading machines and electric owens. Finally there are sometimes little differences in the basic topping: while Italian “pizza margherita” is always made with Italian tomato sauce and mozzarella (traditionally the buffalo mozzarella, but also other types of mozzarella are used) or a soft cheese called “stracchino” (used in place of mozzarella), in American chains tomato sauce tends to be more spiced and sweet, while mozzarella is often mixed with other cheese types (sometimes it is even not present, while you can usually find cheddar).

#ConnectWritingChallenge

31 Likes

Hey @user_not_found that was like attending Pizza-University. Very useful information presented very interestingly. Liked it very much.

2 Likes

@user_not_found I totally loved this post! You explained everything in so much detail.

I honestly did not know all those things about italian pizza. What specially caught my attention is that a person usually eats one entire pizza for lunch or for dinner. Wow! That makes it easier to understand the actual difference to what we usually call pizza outside Italy.

I have my own version of pizza: since I don’t like tomato very much, I only slightly “paint” the dough with the sauce. And since I totally love cheese… I put so much of it as topping! I sometimes like to add a bit of arugula just to add a “healthy” side to it.

I have tried italian pizza when I visited Rome last year and it was super different to what I was used to. Of course I totally loved it anyway :slight_smile:

Thanks for sharing this, and keep up the good writing :slight_smile:

1 Like

@ValeriaA so you may love what we usually call “pizze bianche”, which means “white pizzas”. In Italy also pizzas without tomato sauce are popular. Here you can see an example of pizza with mozzarella cheese, scamorza cheese and chicory.

Obviously a lot of things could be said about Italian mozzarella as well, which is generally not dry like mozzarella I have seen in some USA supermarkets (we have dry mozzarella too but it is not used on pizza).

Talking about eating a whole pizza yeah, it is what we usually do. I have even explained the reasons more in another post, as many people used to not eat an entire pizza would be surely surprised about this fact about Italian pizza.

1 Like

@user_not_found I’m sure that white pizza will be my kind of pizza! I honestly prefer it without the sauce, but I can almost never have it because here we usually share our pizzas, and people usually like it.

I love the fact that you wrote lots of posts about italian cuisine! I will check them out :slight_smile:

1 Like

Hello @user_not_found ,

Thank you for this amazing post and photos, a pizza is always a good option!

Honestly, if the pizza is well done, I love both the Italian and American way. Some Italian friends of mine told me that, pizza and other dishes such as pasta, have become so commercial in Italy, that you need to know where to go in order to have a proper one.

I’m sharing with you a photo that I took at a local pizza shop in Rome.

@BorrisS maybe that is not exactly a pizza shop but a “pinsa” shop. Pinsa is typical of Rome and very similar to pizza and it is typical more long than an ordinary pizza. Can’t see if it is really a “pinsa shop”, but it may be also a pizza takeaway as well.

1 Like

Hello @user_not_found ,

I really don’t know, but what I remember is that there were huge long delicious pizzas and they cut you as much as you want from it. Furthermore, you can eat them there on a table or take them away.

By the way, it’s the first time that I hear about the word pinsa, thank you for the information. :slight_smile: