Request for new category: Bread vending machine

In Belgium, as in some other European countries, bread is a daily ingredient in most people’s menu (often in 2 of the 3 daily main meals).

Typically this is sold in bakeries, of course, but all over the country, there are also vending machines where you can purchase bread at times when bakeries are not opened or in areas where there is no bakery nearby.

Some of them are located just outside a bakery, but those are often entered on Maps as separate POI, which can definitely be justified because of the different opening hours (24/7, whereas the bakery will have 7:00 - 16:00 or so). Others are located near other shops (the picture above is one located next to a newspaper shop) or simply standalone in a residential area.

But they are really all over the place in Belgium, and most of the ones already entered on Maps as POI have the category ‘Bakery’, which is not really accurate, as it suggests a shop with people behind the counter. Some are categorized as ‘Wholesale bakery’ or other food related categories. Here’s a list of 4 of them, randomly picked from different areas of Belgium:

So, my request to enable local guides to improve Maps in Belgium, and the Maps users to have a better experience would be to add a new category: Bread vending machine.

By the way: the bread-idea has already inspired other business owners to set up something similar for their product category, so we’ve already seen vending machines for strawberries, potatoes or even flowers, as you can see in the picture below:

@Ivi_Ge could you please make sure this post gets forwarded to the appropriate team? Thanks!

@KattyGeltmeyer @KristofVaneeck I’m sure you, living in Belgium, will be able to confirm my claim of the ‘Broodautomaten’ all over the country. There will be hundreds, if not thousands of them, I think.

By the way #2: if you are reading this post and you know about bread vending machines in other countries, please do share this info in the comments.

[UPDATE 16/08]
After having read some of the initial comments, it looks like “Fresh food vending machine” might be a better category name (with the type of food then mentioned in the POI name?).

The addition of “fresh” would be needed to distinguish these types of vending machines, which are typically a destination in their own right, from vending machines selling prepacked snacks, which are typically places you encounter when you are on your way to some destination (e.g. at the airport). You could compare that distinction to the one between a trashcan you encounter on the road (not your actual destination and hence not suited to be a POI on Maps) versus a recycling point for glass (which definitely is your destination if you start from your home with a bag of empty bottles and jars - and therefore belongs on Maps).

24 Likes

Hello @JanVanHaver,
I don’t remember having seen a bread vending machine yet, but in Germany it is common that dairy farms sell their products (eggs, milk … etc) this way. In many cases, they might not be located directly at the farm, but closer to a main road nearby.

5 Likes


Hallo @JanVanHaver dieser Hofladen steht in Eckernförde mit unterschiedlichen Lebensmitteln, der Betreiber hat Lebensmittelanbieter als Bezeichnung gewählt.

1 Like

@WilfriedB @Annaelisa those examples would justify a general ‘vending machine’ or ‘fresh products vending machine’ category. Having a separate category per product would be too much in my view.

Thanks for sharing!

3 Likes

@JanVanHaver in fact, I wanted to suggest something like that, but forgot.

1 Like

Oh je @JanVanHaver @WilfriedB sehr umständlich und lang.:grinning_face_with_smiling_eyes:
Lebensmittel-Automat wäre für mich die richtige Bezeichnung

@Annaelisa bist du wirklich Deutsche? Auf Deutsch gibt es normal doch nur extrem lange Wörter? :winking_face_with_tongue::rofl:

2 Likes

Ich hätte den Lebensmittelautomat ja auch zusammen geschrieben, nur das Schreibprogramm hat es lieber wie vorab geschrieben und dann ist es schon wieder ein langes Wort. :joy: @JanVanHaver

1 Like

For many people this would be a VERRY GOOD adding to the map because we all need this some time, and if I look already on the first reactions, I think it’s a great idea @JanVanHaver ! Near where I live I know fruit, bread, food (in several types) and on my recent trip to France I saw several pizza vending machines (fresh???), I didn’t try it :upside_down_face: :joy:. So I’m a huge fan of this idea. And don’t forget “the wall” in The Netherlands where you can take a fresh baked “kroket” from the wall, @JackyB could help, see picture taken from internet.

3 Likes

Hi @Janvanhaver I indeed confirm your claim and if I may dream aloud, it would be a handy thing if we could also search on categories. Suppose that this new category is added and you start with editing, I would like to help you as good as I can. But it’s frustrating when you search for a specific poi type and get a list of many poi’s with correct category, while the ones that are wrongly categorised are not visible directly. I think you remember all the discussions about this we had in the past. I really hope your suggestion for this new category will be accepted and added. Thanks in advance.

2 Likes

Hi @Kristofvaneeck hahaha but that would take me a year to mark all of those snack vending machines :grin:
@JanVanHaver this is a very good idea that you are having, although I didn’t yet see any bread vending machines around.
But we do have dairy, meet, eggs, and in my neighborhood even a vending machine for fresh Roses.
So maybe the topic should be outside vending machines.

3 Likes

That’s very interesting, @JanVanHaver. I thought you were kidding at first, but I never realized how widespread this was!

I’ve never seen a bread vending machine, but here in the US, we have Cupcake ATMs :joy:

1 Like

At the suggestion of @JanVanHaver, I’d like to propose a new category here.

The options in Maps don’t accurately reflect what is meant by “natural monument” in Germany, Austria, and Tyrol:

A natural monument is a naturally formed landscape feature that is protected. A natural monument can be, for example, a single tree, a rock pinnacle, or a cave.

Natural monuments are considered “ambassadors” of environmental awareness, as they impressively demonstrate the diversity of protected areas.

Below are two examples of signs used to indicate a natural monument.

@Ivi_Ge could you please make sure this post gets forwarded to the appropriate team? I don’t know anyone else I can turn to.

@WilfriedB , @LudwigGermany , @MortenCopenhagen

3 Likes

@JackyB

:partying_face: :joy: :+1:

1 Like

Hallo Frau aus den Niederlanden,

Du scheinst einen außergewöhnlichen Humor zu haben :partying_face::flexed_biceps:

ich bin aus Dithmarschen und weiß wovon ich rede