How do you find good restaurants beyond Google Maps star ratings?

Hey everyone!

Since we’re all using Google Maps, I’m curious: How do you decide whether a restaurant or bar is actually worth visiting, apart from its star rating?

I’ve noticed a few things over time:

1. A menu that does everything
If a place offers pizza, burgers, döner kebab and pasta all at once, I’m a bit sceptical. I usually have better experiences at places that focus on one cuisine.

2. Lots of marketing doesn’t mean great quality
Some places are everywhere on social media, while others barely advertise but serve amazing food. I’ve found that the quieter places can sometimes be the real hidden gems.

3. Read the reviews, not just the stars
I don’t just look at whether a place has 4.7 or 3.9 stars. I also read the actual reviews.

For example, I’d be cautious if a restaurant suddenly receives lots of very positive reviews within a short period, especially if many use similar wording or repeatedly praise exactly the same things.

That doesn’t automatically mean the reviews are fake, but it’s worth looking more closely at the overall pattern and the more detailed, balanced reviews.

4. Don’t judge a place by its appearance
Some of the best food can be found in simple, unassuming restaurants. A fancy interior doesn’t always mean a great experience!

5. See where the locals go
Especially in touristy areas, I like to look for places where local people seem to eat regularly.

What about you?

  • What’s your biggest red flag when choosing a restaurant?
  • Do you check photos, menus, negative reviews, or something else?
  • Have you ever stumbled across a hidden gem that turned out to be amazing?

I’d love to hear your tips and experiences. I’m sure there are some great tricks that many of us haven’t thought of yet!

Hi @Pollyx

I would like to add: Getting recommendations from friends and family.

You might be interested in taking a look at

Where a German guy explains how he is developing a system to adjust the star ratings on Google Maps to make them less prone to manipulation (more trustworthy). It’s an interesting concept.

You can learn more here:

I’m not getting any kickback for sharing this.

Thanks for sharing your tip! Really appreciate your input :slight_smile:

Hi @Pollyx

The batch posting of reviews, combined with the fact that these users are leaving their first or second review, naturally raises suspicion. However, it’s also possible that they received a service from a business together and posted their reviews at the same time.

As a Local Guide, an attorney once sent me a long text asking me to post a fake 5-star review, but I refused.

Honestly, there are also fake reviews with text included. These are usually 5-star reviews because no one wants fake 1-star bad reviews for their business.

I am strictly against businesses buying or using fake Google reviews, as I believe deceiving people this way violates other people’s rights and basic fair play.

Hi @Pollyx !

In addition to reading the reviews, I always check their website too. Taking care of how you appear to others online often also represents the care you take towards your customers at the restaurant!

Bye,

David