Easy tips for rating venues and writing structured reviews!

Update 09/09/19: Edited various sections in this post for clarity! It’s almost a rewrite!

Ever found yourself wanting to write a review but then feeling unsure about what to cover? Or perhaps, you started writing out your review and then realised that you’d forgotten to check if the venue had good accessibility, and you’ve already left the place? Well, fret no more! I’ve done all the worrying for you and came up with this simple guide that is easy to remember and also, to follow! This guide will provide you with a reasonably robust structure that should cover almost anything that you would want to review or comment on!

Before we begin, let me remind you that Google provides a guide (see below as well) to how you should rate a place! In my version, I will be tweaking that slightly to match up with the specific categories.

  • :woman_singer: :woman_singer: :woman_singer: :woman_singer: :woman_singer: - Loved it
  • :woman_singer: :woman_singer: :woman_singer: :woman_singer: - Liked it
  • :woman_singer: :woman_singer: :woman_singer: - It was OK
  • :woman_singer: :woman_singer: - Disliked it
  • :woman_singer: - Hated it

My guide is super easy; all you have to remember is to just stick to the FAACTS, which stands for:

F – Food/Drinks :plate_with_cutlery:

  • What this is: Describe your experience with the food/drinks served.
  • Things you can mention: What type of food do they serve? Is it a speciality cocktail bar? Is the food authentic or traditional? Is it tasty? Do they have great vegan options? Gluten-free? Kids/Golden Years (60+) portions? Is the quality high or low? Do they use good ingredients? Are the meals prepared fresh?
  • :woman_singer: :woman_singer: :woman_singer: :woman_singer: :woman_singer: - Your taste buds are in heaven; :woman_singer: :woman_singer: :woman_singer: - It was okay, nothing memorable; :woman_singer: - One to avoid

A – Accessibility :wheelchair:

  • What this is: Describe how accessible the venue is for someone having issues with mobility, sight or sound. Sight and sound are important but can sometimes be secondary because they can be overcome with assistance from staff/public. Mobility, however, can be tricky if there isn’t a proper infrastructure in place!
  • Things to look out for: Is the entrance wide enough for a wheelchair/pram? Do the doors open automatically? Are the doors heavy to open? Is there a ramp leading to the door? What about a chairlift? Are the tables/chairs arranged far away enough to easily walk through? Are there accessible toilets? Menus with braille letterings? Do the staff know how to sign?
  • :woman_singer: :woman_singer: :woman_singer: :woman_singer: :woman_singer: - All areas are fully accessible; :woman_singer: :woman_singer: :woman_singer: - The main areas are accessible but there are still restrictions in other areas; :woman_singer: - Someone with mobility issues will not be able to enter the venue

A – Ambiance :house_with_garden:

  • What this is: Describe how the environment looks and feels! Use all your senses, look around you and observe!
  • Things you can mention: Is it cosy/cramped or sparse/open-planned? Is the dress code casual or is it more of a fine dining experience? Is the venue suitable for big groups, kids or even pets? Is the crowd lively and noisy? Is there an open kitchen? Is there proper ventilation for the cooking smells? Air conditioning? What’s the interior decoration like? Is there a bar area? Have you checked out the toilets? Is it clean? Is there sufficient lighting?
  • :woman_singer: :woman_singer: :woman_singer: :woman_singer: :woman_singer: - It’s clean, beautiful and very welcoming; :woman_singer: :woman_singer: :woman_singer: - Some areas could be improved but generally it’s passable; :woman_singer: - Your body keeps telling you to leave…immediately!

C – Cost :heavy_dollar_sign:

  • What this is: Describe how much it is for the service and whether it is worth paying for.
  • Things you can mention: Is it cheap? How much would an average meal for two people cost? Are the drinks expensive? Is it good value for money? Are there concessions for kids/students/senior citizens? Do they have a happy hour or special discounts?
  • :woman_singer: :woman_singer: :woman_singer: :woman_singer: :woman_singer: - It is cheap or it could be expensive but still worth every single penny; :woman_singer: :woman_singer: :woman_singer: - It is an average cost; :woman_singer: - It is expensive or not worth spending your hard earned money on!

T – Tips :bulb:

  • What this is: Sometimes you have a nugget of information that you’re dying to share to the world, so now’s the time to add it to your review!
  • Things you can mention: Your tips could cover stuff like when’s the regular promotion (e.g. 10% off mains every Wednesday evening) or perhaps there’s a dish that you think that everyone should try or perhaps there’s a secret spot that looks out into the most stunning vista!
  • No ratings needed.

S – Service :bellhop_bell:

  • What this is: Describe the service that you received from staff members!
  • Things you can mention: Were they quick? Attentive or did you have to wave your hands like a lunatic? Did they greet you with big smiles and a warm welcome?
  • :woman_singer: :woman_singer: :woman_singer: :woman_singer: :woman_singer: - Staff felt like family and made your experience amazing; :woman_singer: :woman_singer: :woman_singer: - Service was okay, nothing to write home about; :woman_singer: - You left feeling upset/angry/dumbfounded!

So now that you know and remember this simple guide, how do you put it to practise? Well, at the start, in the middle or at the end of your visit to your venue, keep running through the checklist of points in the guide and jot down notes (or make mental ones). Try, if you can, to cover every point so you know you have not missed anything out!

Of course, you don’t have to write about everything and maybe some stuff are not applicable; pick and choose what’s suitable! Personally, I use any free time I have (waiting for friends to choose what they are ordering, waiting for food to arrive, waiting for the bill etc) to do a quick exploration of the venue, take photos and make my notes.

Similarly, when it comes to rating the venue, I use the FAACTS guide and give each point (except Tips) a star rating out of five! And then calculate the average and round up/down appropriately! If you get an average rating that’s bang in the middle, then you have the power to decide whether you want to round up or down!

In the example above (image of the review is cropped, as it’s really long…you can read it here) I gave the following rating:

Food - 5/5

Ambiance - 3/5

Accessibility - 2/5

Cost - 4/5

Service - 5/5

The total rating is 19/25. And the average is 3.8/5. In this instance, I round it up to 4/5 which is reflected in the Summary rating as well as the final rating that I gave on the app. Rating a venue is always going to be very subjective, but now I feel a bit more confident since I have a structure in place! And most of the times, the final rating (Summary rating) matches up to how I would have normally done my rating!

As a side note, what makes a good review? Again, this is quite subjective since different cultures or people may prefer different things. I would say:

  • Keep it simple and brief; long reviews can be off putting.
  • Keep it detailed and personal; ten reviews saying “good” is not as helpful as one review that goes into detail about why their experience was good!

You may have noticed that I’ve said to keep it brief but also detailed! Yes, it’s about getting the right balance. For myself, I’ve decided that moving forward, I should only write 1-2 sentences for each point in my FAACTS guide. Indeed, the overall review is still going to be long, but it’s as detailed and brief as I can possibly make it. You can also find out some great reviewing tips here from Google!

As my review can end up longer than the average review, I also started to play with different formatting. I’ve tried different styles of star ratings, single vs multiple paragraphs, topic headings etc. Here are some examples:

Full review of Carluccio’s

Full review of In Flanders Fields Museum

Full review of Yuzu

All this experimenting is still new (I started a few months back) and I’ve yet to settle on one particular style but I think I like the visual emoji stars and structured paragraphs the best because it makes it easy for the reader to pick and choose what information they want to read up on. Like 'em or hate 'em, emojis in a review can be quite effective and I need to remember to use hashtags too!

I hope you will find this guide to be useful! I’m sure everyone has their own ways and if you have any tips or advice, please do share them! I’m still learning and refining my methods and hopefully, one day, I will nail it! Until then, I’m keen to know how you write your reviews so fire away in the comments below! If you can, please include a link or screenshots to your review so that we can all easily see how you’re writing them! Thanks for reading and sharing!!

#ConnectWritingChallenge

261 Likes

What a great tutorial, @AdrianLunsong ! I hope folks find this helpful as they’re crafting reviews!

34 Likes

Great post dear @AdrianLunsong
Keep up to share the informative posts.
Thank you for sharing

Best Regards
Rezgar

14 Likes

Thank you. @AdrianLunsong for sharing, I will add on what I have to improve and use different formats you shared here.

15 Likes

Hi @AdrianLunsong ,

This post is simply amazing as of big importance of all of us. These tips are great and loved your effective way to split the reviews by FAACTS with their relevant ratings. This makes order by reviewing places. Thank you, I will consider as Guide for my next reviews.

11 Likes

Thanks @TraciC @Rezgar @Raphael-Mahumane @Giuseppe75 !

Glad you all enjoyed the post! Using the FAACTS structure really helps me to remember what I should be looking out for beyond just the dish in front of me (food is such a seductive creature!), and it’s also a gentle reminder to keep reviews factual!! :slight_smile:

17 Likes

Hey @OmerAli @Ambreen (I still remember your post about standardised review/template) and also @TopHatKat (your merged idea/suggestion from the Idea Exchange). What are your thoughts on this method?

13 Likes

Experimenting is a great idea, @AdrianLunsong , and I think you’ve knocked this method out of the park! I really love the acronym and its very helpful and easy to remember in terms of covering those important aspects. I prefer to just write everything out as a concise narrative as you do without the individual categorical ratings, but this is still is very helpful for remembering the aspects that users are usually keen on. Love it!

13 Likes

It is so useful dear @AdrianLunsong

8 Likes

Hello, @AdrianLunsong

Thank you for sharing these nice tips!

In addition to it, I definitely check the ways to payment and the free wi-fi spot. In Japan, they are very important:-)

11 Likes

This is really helpful @AdrianLunsong , ticked all the boxes. Will keep in mind when writing reviews and will also share it in my local community

7 Likes

@AdrianLunsong very helpful post.

Many times I feel what you are describing here.

How to cover all the items in a review and at the same time being sintetic and easy to read And closer as possible to the reality of your experience.

If I’m not wrong it would be in Spanish a sort of:

CAACCS

Comida

Accesibilidad

Ambiente

Costo

Consejos

Servicio

Again , helpful post helps to improve the art of reviewing, thanks.

Regards!

8 Likes

@AdrianLunsong Thank you for sharing this review style with us. When you give Cost - 1/5, does it mean that it is expensive? And Cost - 5/5, is it cheap? I’m not sure the readers will understand this point. As 1/5 is low, and 5/5 is high to me, not sure about others. What do you think?

7 Likes

Excellent proposal @AdrianLunsong ,
In fact, 5-level evaluation has been considered difficult to handle in statistical discussions. A 10-level rating is desirable, but if we want to control this simple style precisely, a detailed 5-level rating display divided as you indicated would be ideal in practice!

6 Likes

Hi @AdrianLunsong

Thank you so much for tagging me, this is so helpful and I am glad that you are making this effort of helping people write standard reviews. I personally feel map reviews are so important factor to help people make better decisions. So this is definitely a great format to have. I can share my personal journey on Google maps, I love writing detailed reviews describing my experience and then I like to sum it up with highlight points. I also have some set formats which I have been following over the years for different industries and even shared these with @OmerAli as well. There are so many factors which you can consider depending on the USP of the brand, company, institution, its ideologies etc… which you plan to review.

For example: Restaurants also have different types of categories like - Dine in, Fine dine, takeaway outlet, exclusive home dining experience outlets, delivery kitchens, pub, dessert shop, coffee shop, bakeries etc… then there are various other deciding factors like hygiene, restrooms or some food courts in malls even have the facility of mom baby care feeding rooms, then factors like accessibility, seating, ambiance etc…

I mostly consider the below format to review a restaurant based on which I derive the overall value for money score. I also like to talk to the restaurant owners or staff to understand a little bit about the history and inception of the place.

My Experience:

1.Food Taste:
2. Food Presentation:
3. Ambiance:
4. Entertainment Factors: (Live sports screening? Karaoke? Music? Live performance? dance floor? etc…)
5. Type?: Pub (City Nightlife)? Family dine in? Fine Dine? etc…
6. Parking Availability? Valet?
7. Seating: (Outdoor/Indoor Ac/ Non Ac?)
8. Service:
9. Staff:
10: Quality of food: Hygiene?
11. Quantity of food: (serving portions?)
12. Wheelchair Accessible Entrance:
13: Restroom:
14. Is Table booking recommended?
15.Any healthy options? Keto Options?
16. LGBTQIA Friendly?
17. Kids friendly?
17. Prices: Inexpensive? Moderate? Expensive?
18. Home delivery?
19. Cuisines: Chinese? Asian? Italian? Continental?
20. Outlets: How many outlets it has?
21. Best timings to visit for grab happy hour offers?
Historic location?
USP ? Signature dishes/ chef specials?
Anything interesting people must know about this place?
Overall Value For Money example - 5
/5

Then similarly if I am reviewing for example Hospital then I consider various important factors like - timings you can visit the patient, procedure, facilities, rules and regulations, prices, amenities, hygiene, any medical shops around or inside the complex, service, doctors, staff, canteen food, how helpful are people at the help desk, emergency helpline numbers, any good doctor recommendations etc…

So @AdrianLunsong I am super happy to see your post and wish you all the very best hope people can learn and this will definitely assist them in writing better quality helpful reviews :slight_smile:

Thanks & Regards

@Ambreen

9 Likes

Thanks @SP31 ! In a rush, I also default to a short paragraph but as you said, I use the FAACTS guide to help me figure out what’s worth mentioning. :slight_smile: Hope all is well with you by the way!!

6 Likes

Ooh… interesting @HiroyukiTakisawa !! Could you elaborate on the payment info? Are there places that won’t accept cash? Both payment type and WiFi availability are great additions and can be covered under Tips! I definitely should keep them in mind especially the WiFi one! Very useful to know!

5 Likes

Thanks very much for the kind words @AslamMo ! Glad you like it and happy to share it with your community!

@SebaasC Thanks as well to you! I know only basic Spanish but really nice to see the translation! As @SP31 mentioned the FAACTS guide is an easy acronym to remember since it’s word play on “facts” which is what all reviews should be based on. Maybe you can come up with a Spanish acronym that is similar; something easy to remember and a word play on something related/appropriate? You can use an online anagram solver to help out! Unfortunately CAACCS didn’t come up with anything!

7 Likes

@Ant_Bad_Yogi Thanks for pointing this out! Yes, I need to clarify in the post as the structure for awarding the stars on Costs is counterintuitive! As you’ve mentioned ratings for costs usually go as $, $$ and $$$ where $ means cheap and $$$ means expensive. However, for this rating to work, the more stars you give, the better it is. So for Costs, I would classify the stars as:

1/5 = Expensive and a waste of your money

2/5 = Expensive

3/5 = Affordable

4/5 = Cheap

5/5 = Cheap and good value for money

So a 5/5 rating would mean that not only is the food cheap but you’re getting more than your money’s worth because it’s either very tasty, authentic, unique etc… stuff that you probably wouldn’t be able to get elsewhere. I’ll modify my post later to reflect this! Thanks again for pointing this out!!! Much appreciated!!

6 Likes

Thanks @YasumiKikuchi I actually prefer 5 levels to 10 levels! I vaguely remember seeing an article somewhere of how Google decided to remove ratings for a simple Like/Dislike button for a specific app/function but I can’t find it. In any case I think the 5 levels is sufficient because the 10 levels would introduce some small differences between each level which is hard to gauge.

For instance, if I were to use emoji to represent the levels:

1 - :slightly_frowning_face:

2 - :expressionless:

3 - :slightly_smiling_face:

1 - :frowning:

2 - :slightly_frowning_face:

3 - :expressionless:

4 - :slightly_smiling_face:

5 - :grinning:

But to do 10 levels… would this be it?

1 - :face_with_symbols_over_mouth:

2 - :persevere:

3 - :frowning:

4 - :slightly_frowning_face:

5 - :expressionless:

6 - :slightly_smiling_face:

7 - :blush:

8 - :grinning:

9 - :heart_eyes:

10 - :exploding_head:

10 Likes