Auto drawing for roads caused wrong shapes and routing on the map!

Hello,

We all know that since closure of Map Maker users can not draw roads and they only should report missing roads or needed changes.

On the other hand we know that Google is working on Artificial Intelligence to draw map automatically based on satellite images. This is very good idea in areas that we have good quality for satellite images and I was thought that Google will not start such project in areas with low quality satellite images like Iran.

But recently we received many reports (in Iran Local Guides community) that shows very bad drawing of road in many parts of the road. For example marking pedestrians only roads open for cars or creating totally wrong roads only based on visible path on satellite image. This caused very wrong shapes on the map of Iran (and maybe other countries with similar conditions) and also wrong addressing for users. For example wrong routing through dead ends those marked as open on the map automatically!

Previously we asked a lot to re-enable drawing for users (at least for some best users) but not only it didn’t enable again, but now smart drawing made road problems double! So what is the solution right now? If it was in small area we could report needed changes but we received such reports in many parts of the map of Iran.

These are very cases but only as example to clarify my explanation:

Another example of changing pedestrians only roads to local roads:

Example of wrong routing:

Now there is very bad situation on the map and this cause less and less use of Google Maps and less relying on it :frowning:

Is there any way to reverse such recent changes?

Is there any way to enable drawing of the roads at least for some users and limited time to fix errors?

Your help is appreciated dear Googlers

@AriMar @Atsukot

41 Likes

Please help, this is making the sparse map even worse!

Another example:

@AriMar @NadyaPN @BorrisS

I feel your pain my friend!

For someone like you who has been participating with accurate map details in Map Maker for more than a decade… then seeing this AI-generated disaster!

Artificial Intelligence will work best in more modern and accurately constructed roads in Europe and western countries, but in many other countries, it will just continue to make scrappy additions to the map. They need to watch the quality of its additions closely.

I hope they fix this soon, but keep documenting such errors and also send them ā€˜General Feedback’ through Google Maps application, because these are your best chances to fix them currently.

My suggestion for such posts in Connect Community is to add pictures, description of the problem, and the link to the same place on Google Maps because when -in best odds- someone sees the post, it would be a lot better that all details are there to make their action faster.

1 Like

Hi @Amiran ,

Thank you for reaching out. I understand that these types of errors on the Map can be frustrating at times, but the best thing you can do in these situations is to report the incorrect information by sending a feedback. Bellow you can find the step how you can rectify such mistakes on Google Maps:

  1. On your Android phone or tablet, open the Google Maps app;
  2. Tap Menu (burger menu) > Send feedback > Wrong information;
  3. Select the affected road;
  4. From the list that appears at the bottom, tap the place or road you want to fix;
  5. Tap Closed or blocked;
  6. To report your issue, fill out the form;
  7. Tap Send.

Hope you’ll find the information above helpful.

3 Likes

Thanks @JafferA I’ll try to prepare more documentations.

I know that way dear @KlaudiyaG and I do in cases I see but firstly these days the team pay less attention to road reports and moreover this is not one or some cases. There are lots of such errors on vast area on the map that created recently by AI and it needs attention more than one general way to report road problems. I think something like known issue thread about spams in Russia and Ukraine and around countries is needed but this time about AI faults :wink:

Hello dear @KlaudiyaG

Please remove the solution tag from the thread because nothing solved!

I’m too busy and because of this writing and collecting documentations takes long but I’ll prepare info one by one bellow this post.

As start, the wrong roads I’ve reported last month still exists and should be removed:

https://goo.gl/maps/pUQvWQ3CDmWgTVLg7

https://goo.gl/maps/Gm9prxbMp2Kv66Xp6

https://goo.gl/maps/QgRG8qBqiMwo76qX8

Some other wrong roads those should be removed in Arak city:

https://goo.gl/maps/uWbM21G9JzzdRK9r9

https://goo.gl/maps/dnqXWijiZ7xJ47Rh8

https://goo.gl/maps/QyCL8rudQcAJR2iz9

https://goo.gl/maps/2f6kmohP2QJzEZsv9

https://goo.gl/maps/5BNHnya99PY6vGFP7

https://goo.gl/maps/u8NJd8EZpzFXtWAf6

These are also dead end for cars (with a path only for pedestrians) those smart system connected to main road!

https://goo.gl/maps/5YqYRorsJSrbgbrb6

https://goo.gl/maps/J2LcdiMogSLWXWYg6

Excuse me dear @ErmesT , may you please remove ā€œSolutionā€ tag? The problem I discussed about, didn’t solve yet! And this tag causes less attention to the problem although this is a big problem in vast area. Even our road reports has no effect after months and many Iranian users is telling about denial of their reports except adding name to the unnamed road.

what is the point of reporting a problem when nobody’s going to fix it? i did a lot of fix but none of them was approved! it keep saying ā€œGoogle couldn’t verify your editā€, it’s frustrating!

there was ā€œgoogle map makerā€ before, and it was very good for editing local problems such this but i don’t know why they removed it!?

this is not useful at all! tell me if you have a better solution and i will start to contribute over again.