Hi All,
I’m really trying to understand the whole Not Applied - Place Creation issue and cannot find any solution, it’s got to the point of discouraging me from contributing new locations after putting lots of effort into taking photos of seemingly obvious missing public locations only to have the location rejected.
Please see one example attached. A photo of a sign with the location name and a listing on the councils website. I don’t understand what more could be required. Am I doing something wrong or is this really the way the system works?!
Can photos be added to the submission proving the place name and existence?
A way to request a review with more information attached?
Some information as to why it was rejected so I can improve my submissions?
Does something exist where one can register with Google to be approved to verify locations?
I enjoy contributing but without a solution to this issue it’s difficult to justify the effort to take photos of new locations.
Hey @PortraitsInThePark
“If your edit is Not Applied, that means we were unable to confidently verify the information you shared at this time.”
Please find more information here in this pinned post.
If Google could trust everyone to always make good edits then there would never be rejections, but unfortunately those that purposely or innocently add bad data have resulted in the need for filters.
Place creation requires a lot of information including exact GPS location, any existing POI, and exactly what data you were trying to add or edit. With that mapping experts can look it over and let you know if there are obvious and/or likely issues that you can fix in your next attempt.
Hi @VinayKrishna
Thank you for you reply but that still doesn’t address my issue or provide any confidence to start submitting new locations.
I understand the message “unable to confidently verify the information” but why? how can that be when the information about the location is listed on a reputable website, being the local Councils website and the location text is legible from Googles own street view. I’m seeking more information into the verification process so I know what new locations to put the effort into taking photos of and submit. At the moment to me if this location can be rejected anything can, it’s completely random.
The information in the link provided does not apply to my issue as this as a public park/location, there is no copyright being infringed.
“If Google could trust everyone to always make good edits then there would never be rejections, but unfortunately those that purposely or innocently add bad data have resulted in the need for filters.”
This quote just tells me Google doesn’t trust anyone, therefore a filter is in place that randomly rejects anything including government listed parks with no other options to get the location listed. This doesn’t seem right to me or a very robust verification process that I’m prepared to gamble my time on.
Place creation requires a lot of information including exact GPS location: My location questioned has that
Any existing POI: There is no other POI in the area it’s an isolated, beautiful picnic area that has tables and stairs that lead down to the water.
Exactly what data you were trying to add or edit: I right clicked on the map and added a missing place, then filled in all the available fields
With that mapping experts can look it over and let you know if there are obvious and/or likely issues that you can fix in your next attempt: This is the point of my post and what I want to know, I’ve provided all the information I have in the submission, it is clearly a location that exists I want to know what is the process to get it reviewed and listed.
Hi @PortraitsInThePark ,
Thanks for reaching out.
Please be advised that there are certain items in Google Maps that you cannot edit and these include landmarks, established points-of-interests or even the names of a city/township - Only Google can edit these although you can always send feedback and suggest your changes through Google maps.
Hi @PortraitsInThePark
Adding a park as an area (polygon) rather than a point is beyond the edit in power We local guides are trusted with.
The only way forward is to provide feedback. Use these Steps to send feedback. And you should attach proof of different kinds. The more official the better. Also official local maps showing the entire polygon is needed.
Alternatively you can reach out to the relevant local mapping authorities and encourage them to ask Google to fix this. And/or you can team up with other local guides so they will hear from different local guides as a way to verify the existence of the park.
This is not easy. We have all been there. We recognize your frustration.
Later. With experience you will have a more clear idea about what types of additions you can add without problems. And then you will waste less of your time.
But it is tough.
Best of luck.
Hi @MashaPS
Thank you, this is the sort of information I wanted to know. I’m not editing anything just adding something that doesn’t exist on Google Maps but exists in city records.
I’m starting to get a picture of why it was not created, being a major reserve that only Google will add, it’s omission in the first place seems to be an error but I still don’t have the level of privilege to add this type of item. Minor items like public toilets and play areas haven’t been a problem.
My issue with this particular location was I spent a lot of time creating a virtual tour and photos etc. Lesson learned!
My solution will be to add a place first or on the spot with my phone and then if I get a chance go back to the location and photograph it. If not added no time wasted, at least it may be approved at some point and be on the map for others to add to, I just may not get points for first photos of a location 
Hi @MortenCopenhagen
This is excellent and reassuring information, appreciate your message. It confirms I’m on the right track and just have to work around. I replied to another message which is thanks to your message also.
In summary for others my solution will be to add a place first or on the spot with my phone and then if I get a chance go back to the location and photograph it. If not added no time wasted, at least it may be approved at some point and be on the map for others to add to, I just may not get points for first photos of a location 