True negative review removed after 1 star rating, please restore it

I had reviewed the below dental clinic 1 star after my horrible experience, but the business owner has been manipulating reviews by removing the negative ones and only keeping positive reviews.

I strongly believe this is against free speech and the customer has every right to give negative reviews, and business owner should not have the liberty to remove negative feedback, instead learn from his/her wrongdoings and provide better service in future.
I believe Google as a company is in alignment to free speech.
This is clear manipulation for customers.
Hence, I request you to please restore my 1 star review against this dental clinic. Review link: https://goo.gl/maps/9UQoRQAwYp9wXUFd7
Below is the listing on google maps
https://maps.app.goo.gl/g6UEqvo78C6i6wPM8

I look forward to hearing from you.

@ashish-chourasia

Removal of reviews can only be done if the review violates Google’s guidelines for reviews. A business can not get a review removed just because it is negative or because they don’t like it.

So your strategy should include studying the guidelines. Currently none off my 614 reviews are hidden.

If you share the review text below I can take a look to see if you violated one or more guidelines. Please remember to tag me.

Cheers

Morten

Hi @ashish-chourasia

I fully agree with @MortenCopenhagen

A review is not removed because negative. A review is made private when it violates the Maps User Contributed Content Policy

Check the content and edit the review to remove what is inappropriate will make your review visible again.

What I find totally inappropriate is to create a second Local Guides account, and a “call to action” of families and friends for writing a wave of negative reviews. All this are serious violations of the rules, as you are trying to downgrade the rating of the business. All the accounts, including yours, should be permanently banned because of this activity.

My tip for you is:

  • Remove IMMEDIATELY ALL the fake reviews.
  • Leave the program with the other account
  • Edit your review to respect the rules, to make it visible again

This doesn’t mean that I trust that business, as the waves of reviews that they have is quite suspicious too, but everything should be appropriate in both sides (reviews and business)

The spam name of the business, as you can see, has been already fixed, and a report will be raised ASAP, to report ALL the violations on both sides

Thank you so much @MortenCopenhagen for your effort, it means a lot to me.

Below is the review I had put in it’s entirety

- Dr RXXXX is an excellent doctor, he is very experienced, gentle and his treatment is always top notch.

- I’m undergoing orthodontics treatment, and so far the progress has been excellent. I’ve also had composite fillings, extractions, scaling done from him, everything was smooth and painless.

- Hygiene is never compromised here, they do sanitization of equipments always before calling next patient.

Highly recommended :smiley: :smile:
Update: (I wrote above review back in 2021)
----------------------------------------------------
FYI: I edited below review today 8th July 2022
Update: Horrible and unexpected experience at the end with my ortho treatment with RXXXX

Context: I’m a Software Engineer by profession (based out of Bangalore), and my company is asking employees to return back to offices from May 2022 itself as covid cases have dropped.
Since my ortho treatment is not over, it’d be very hard for me to travel back and forth between Bangalore and Bhopal. So ideally, I wished to go to Bangalore after my treatment was over.
So I’ve been constantly asking my manager and HR to make an exception for me and extend Work from home (WFH). They’ve already considered me as exceptional case and I’ve already extended for 3months.

1. RXXXX promised me that my ortho treatment will be over by January 2022. Today is 8th July 2022, and my treatment is not over. Although that’s still fine, I avoided pointing this out to him.
2. My ortho progress went downhill and then subsequently plateaued with no signs of improvement in the last 7 months. I kept reminding him in each visit from last 2 months that I have to go back by 16th July and cannot extend WFH further. He had suggested me that we can anytime close the gap with teeth veneers, and I’ve been requesting him for the same in my previous appointments.
3. Today (8th July 2022) RXXXX told me I’ll have to get Hawleys retainer (which is very noticeable and uncomfortable as wire sits in front). In my previous appointments, he had always suggested that I’ll get fixed bonded retainer at the back of my teeth (upper and lower) which I was perfectly fine with.
4. My only concern was: Why I was not told about Hawleys retainer beforehand? I’ve been regularly visiting the clinic without missing any appointments. Initially when payment was due, they used to schedule my appointments, but after the ortho payment was over, it has always been me who calls and schedules it.
5. When I asked RXXXX why he never mentioned Hawleys retainer earlier, and why he is surprising me when only 1 week is left for me to leave for Bangalore, he rained down hell on me. He made a scene at his clinic. He shouted at me, demoralized me in his clinic and denied treatment and told me to look elsewhere for my ortho treatment. This has left me traumatized.
6. I spoke with him in a calm tone, but he kept shouting till the end and told me to get out of clinic. I complied and silently exited from the clinic.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Update: It’s 1am, 9th July 2022, and I’m writing this as I can’t sleep because of horrible experience he gave me today.
Initially for first ~1 year of braces/ortho treatment RXXXX had treated me with good care, but that substantially declined once ortho payment was over.
It’s like he deprioritized me after payment was over and I felt my subsequent sittings to be rushed despite patiently waiting 45min/1hr for my turn at the clinic.

For instance: During my teeth cleaning, he didn’t do a good job with the bottom teeth, and I had to point it out to him multiple times to get it cleaned properly, only then he agreed, and that too hesitatingly.

TLDR: After taking all the payment, shouting and demoralizing me infront of his patients at his clinic when I asked him simple question, he decided not to take my treatment forward.
As a result I’ll have to look for a different dentist which altogether will cost me more money and time.

PS: Added some screenshots supporting my experience with RXXXX.

Edit: removed screenshots

Hi @ErmesT

This dentist has been removing all the negative reviews from his clinic behind everyone’s back. It’s unfair to do so.

He had removed my genuine review (which I shared below as requested by @MortenCopenhagen ), only then I shared with my friends what I went through, and hence they started giving him 1 star review as well.

I understand the concern raised by you. I will personally ask and ensure that my friends and families have deleted their reviews once my original review is restored. Will that be ok? @ErmesT

@ashish-chourasia

You need to get all reviews made by your friends on your behalf deleted right away. You are likely to be suspended for this.

The spam filter is very sensitive to long texts. The more words the more like the spam filter will be triggered.

Also, you are using words like horrible.

I have described Revenge reviews as an issue in this post:

https://www.localguidesconnect.com/t5/General-Discussion/Common-Review-Violations/td-p/2901625

I’m afraid your long review is in this category. If you think like a Maps user a more helpful review would be very short and straight to the point. I don’t think anyone will read your review in its entirety. And I think many will think that the dentist has a very different version of events.

You risk legal action and I suggest you don’t use Google Maps to let off steam in this way.

Best of luck

Morten

You wrote: “I will personally ask and ensure that my friends and families have deleted their reviews once my original review is restored. Will that be ok?”.

ermest_0-1657384044075.png

No, @ashish-chourasia , it doesn’t work that way. Their reviews are not showing a personal experience, but a simple revenge through an attack of the business, and this is also confirmed in your reply. Your sentence is only a fast track to be banned.

We are talking about 25 reviews so far written by you and your friends, and the wave is continuing while we are talking. This is totally unacceptable!

Your review is a blend of personal fact, related to your work and your life, and a personal rant about the business and your relationship with them. Also for your own privacy please remove the screenshots of the conversation between you and the business, as this is totally irrelevant. The algorithm of Maps do not have the scope of Judging if you are right or not, but simply to evaluate if your review is respecting the rules.

As @MortenCopenhagen said, the risk of this review is to get a Legal Action, so by removing it Maps is also helping you to avoid the risk.

If the clinic is not respecting the contract, the appropriate thing to do is to take a Legal Action, not to use Google Maps for your scope

Haha, @ErmesT

Now the dentist started a counter offensive by getting friends and familie or staff to write 5 star reviews within the past few hours. Or maybe she is paying for fake positive reviews all to dilute the effect of fake negative reviews from @ashish-chourasia and his friends!

What a mess.

Cheers

Morten

Hi @MortenCopenhagen @ErmesT

Thanks for your constant support. It truly means a lot to me.

I edited my review (shortened it significantly) and it’s public now. That was all I wanted. My voice to be heard in fullest.
I’ve asked each of my friends and family to remove the review, and most have already removed with rest on the way.

According to my screenshots, @MortenCopenhagen , the latest negative review is from 10 minutes ago.

You edited the review, @ashish-chourasia , and it is now public? So you started a war for nothing, unable to understand that the review was not removed by the business!

Hope at least you understood what you caused

Well, hope this is a great opportunity for Google Maps for a bit of clean-up, @MortenCopenhagen , removing 27 accounts that were supporting this senseless action, a business that is buying positive reviews in Google Maps, and a countless number of profiles that are offering positive reviews.

This is a great conclusion, Don’t you agree?

Sure, @ErmesT

It is not that often I see such blatant dual-side violations in real time.

Cheers

Morten

Apologies for inconvenience caused @ErmesT and @MortenCopenhagen but I thought the business had removed my review itself.

Because whenever I tried to resubmit my current review, it wouldn’t let me. I thought business had flagged me as spam and thus I was unable to add new reviews there.

Now I’m able to connect the dots, and I guess it was removed by Google under Google’s content policy as you linked me earlier.

I swear I was totally unaware that something like this exists until you pointed it out to me.

I’ve been actively trying to undo all the negative reviews from my friends, and as of now only 8-10 of them remain. I understand that what I’ve done was wrong but I was totally unaware about Google’s content policy, and was under the impression that the business removed my review.

At the other end, let’s not ignore the fact that this business is promoting themselves using fake 5 star reviews since god knows so long!

Because they were able to get so many positive reviews from relatively new people (who have 1-5 reviews in total) in short amount of time!

Apologies once again. I learnt a lesson today the hard way.

I’m sorry, @ashish-chourasia , but it is late to apologize. You wrote a post here nine and a half hour ago, asking for help.

On the meantime, while talking with me and @MortenCopenhagen , you started a “call to action” against a business. An action made with 27 accounts, several of them also duplicate, pretending to justify this because you were thinking that the review was removed by the business. When I invited you to stop, you responded that you will stop only when your review will be back, even if we explained that you was doing something against the rules.

And now you say that you are sorry, and you learned a lesson in the hard way?

I am sorry for you, but it is too late to be sorry.

As @MortenCopenhagen well know, this is not my usual language, but really what you did is well over the limits. You missed the most important point, that is the respect of others and the possibility of giving the benefit of doubt.

In a war there are no winners, and you intentionally started a war.

Regarding the business, in my opinion it is inappropriate too, but this does justify your actions.

Yeah @MortenCopenhagen , to see “live” what happens can be indeed interesting

Hi @ErmesT

Please hear me out just one last time, and then please let me know your views once.

  1. I made this post 11hours ago as I thought the business owner had removed my review from his page.

  2. Unknown to me at the time of writing this post, my review was actually removed by Maps user-generated content policy

  3. After seeing my review removed, I thought business owner has flagged me and that’s why after multiple attempts of trying to submit the review, I was unable to do so.

  4. After this, I discussed this with my friends, and asked them to post the same on my behalf

  5. My friend’s reviews also got removed (due to google’s content policy, this was unknown to everyone of us)

  6. I got angry and thought business owner had been actively manipulating the reviews. I thought he quickly removes negative reviews somehow.

  7. As a last resort (where I made the biggest mistake) I asked my friends to give him 1 rating as I thought he is a total fraud.

Please read the stuff I wrote above, and think of it from my point of view. We (me and friends) were all unknown to Maps user-generated content policy

Had I known this policies earlier, this wouldn’t have happened. Hence I apologize on my end.

Attached screenshot from WhatsApp conversation with my friends.

CC: @MortenCopenhagen

Edit: removed screenshots

@ashish-chourasia

We can all make mistakes, but the guidelines are in my opinion basically common sense and normal decency. So not knowing the guidelines (that you accepted when signing up as a local guide) is not a real excuse.

You can’t do much more than keep cleaning up and hope for the best.

Morten

PS I recommend you remove the screenshots not to implicate more people and for privacy.

Again, @ashish-chourasia , I have to agree with @MortenCopenhagen .

Not knowing the policies can never be an excuse to justify a mass attacks to a business.

Recently Google Maps added a link to the rules near every single review, you had just to click on the (i) to get the link

The only thing you can do is to remove all the fake reviews, and to hope and cross your fingers.

Good luck

@MortenCopenhagen You said “Removal of reviews can only be done if the review violates Google’s guidelines for reviews.”

This is definitely not true. I am often noticing any 1-star review I post get removed, and I never post anything that is untrue or violating the guidelines. This system is rigged.