Thirty Days Later: What My Last Post Got Right and Wrong

About 3 weeks ago, I shared my research into Maps upload and feature statistics. Using my media upload pattern and featuring in (top 20) of a locations and tracking it about a month as I noticed significant drop after about a month of featuring.
I made some stratistical prediction, so now I went back to the same locations to see if I was right.

Starting from the end: I was.
The one-month pattern held, even in cities far from my first trip.
The reassuring 95% of keeping featured media that I reported last time was too early, though. Today 83% of my featured places are still featured.

My prediction came true

Last time I picked one group of places whose best photo was just about to turn 30 days old.
I assumed that they would probably lose 40 to 50% of their positions. They lost 57%.
I also checked whether my own new uploads (to same place) caused it, because a new photo can push an older one down. Without those places the loss is still 50%, so the upload age IS what matters.

It is the age of the photo, not the date on the calendar

Think of the date on a carton of milk. If Maps changed something on one particular day, all my places would have changed together. Instead, each place changed when its own photo reached about 30 days.
Places that passed the ~30 day mark between my two checks jumped from 7% to 58% losing ground. Places that were already past 30 days stayed about where they were.

It also happened everywhere, not only on my Wiltshire trip. Amsterdam went from 6% to 58% and Tokyo from 5% to 63%.
Meaning (currently) when maps is evaluting “refresh” needs, one month of featuring is a check point for keeping or replacing.

After 30 days it is a coin flip

Last time I wondered if the “oldest” photos had become safe (e.g. if they held past 30 days, they would keep featuring for long). They have not.
Between 30 and 60 days old, about half of my places lose ground, and the loss does not get better as the photo gets older. Only places with photos older than 60 days look calmer, at 17%, and even that number is slowly rising.

Not surprising: Busy places refreshes more frequently

A popular place gets new photos from many people, so there are more of them “competing” for the same top spots.
Again, using number of reviews as “popularity” index:
For places with a photo 30 to 59 days old, I lost position at 38% of the places with under 100 reviews, but at 81% of the places with 500 reviews or more. At those busy places 59% lost their spot in the top 20 completely.

The more (featured), the better

Naturally, Multiple (Two and more) featured photos at the same place, worked like a “safety” net.
Only 3 of my 103 places with two or more featured media items (by me) lost every feature, against 20% of places with just one.
The net does not stop the slide, but it keeps the place alive.

My new uploads, since those original batches, are also doing fine.
About 94% of the newer photos that were featured on 8 October still are.
Videos, which started slower than photos, have caught up: 58% of my videos are now featured, against 53% of photos.

I also said last time that views seem to take about two-three days to start showing up. That is still roughly true, but my age estimates this time are too rough to prove it, so I would not quote the exact number.
Finally, I still cannot say whether photos older than 60 days are “safer” (e.g. would take longer before being replaced), or just the survivors.

Beyond understanding, what it means

If you really want to maximize your impact and have time for strategy:
For popular places, treat 30 days as a “Cut off”, and try to keep a second great media there (Revisit or upload later).
For quiet places relax, because a feature there tends to slide down instead of disappearing.
This is my own reading of one contributor’s data, so please treat it as a hint and not a rule. Have you seen the same drop at around a month on your own photos? I would love to compare.

Earlier posts in the series: my million-view photos, still popular?, 1,106 places later.

Most important: Keep Contributing!
Sam

Tagging data hungry LGs
@tony_b @TerryPG @MortenCopenhagen @Annaelisa @StevenBerlin @Kurt2day @PrasadVR @WilfriedB

@abermans , @tony_b @MortenCopenhagen @Annaelisa @StevenBerlin @PrasadVR @WilfriedB

Great comparison @abermans !! 200% Interesting ! :tada::tada:

Some thoughts.

We should have some input from someone who knows how those algos work or function in general. (Free) AI advice is guidance but it currently makes many mistakes.

It would be interesting to compare the following (it would require a lot of work).

1/ If one of your images has taken over the main spot, which (type of) image is it and which (type of) image has it replaced? And, which business category is it.

2/ GBPs get constantly new contributions, so when your image was the main image, which new (type of) image has replaced yours ?

Then, we would know which type of image Google prefers for a certain category of business. Of course, nobody can control user engagement with a photo. Only viewing is counted. A very colorful image probably gets more user engagement than a not-so-colorful photo.

I don’t think that time plays an active role behind the changes. It’s just that Google thinks there is a new image that is more relevant (or has the same relevance, but the image is fresher). Some categories get many contributions, others not so many. Some categories get photos every day. In each category, there are probably some that have more reviews and also more images.

I think there is a logic of ‘a helpful image’ etc. and that’s difficult to describe. A 45 angle ? An interior shot ? An exterior frontal shot ? A product shot … They are all fresh, but there are so many nuances and if you’re lucky, picture A gets more engagement than your picture B…

I think our photos are just kicked out because the new one is more ‘helpful’ (algos), is fresher (objective) and gets more user engagement (not controllable).

Regarding VIDEO, there is a clear trend that Google likes it. We are getting used to seeing videos on all the social media platforms. On mobile (Android), the main image is often a video, when a video is available. Many listings still have no video.

Please share your thoughts.

@Kurt2day I understand the need to find answers to why the algorithm chooses certain images, but imo, and many might disagree, we will not find this answer.

It has nothing to do with clarity, composition, or symmetry, or w/e you think makes a photo better. I have seen photos on a slant, blurred, with someone’s face partially in and out of frame be featured for weeks. To me, that speaks volumes.

However, just because I think this, doesn’t mean its true, nor should it ever prevent anyone from taking a well-composed, clear, good quality image to represent maps.

@StevenBerlin . Me too, I’ve seen many photos that violate the guidelines. Even from LG level 10. It seems that many are not aware that there are guidelines and that they available on the GBP and MAPS forum. At the same time, I also know (everybody knows) that Google is not perfect and that there are bugs. IMO, the algos make (too many) mistakes and that’s why we can made edits on listings and choose ‘not helpful’, ‘photo not of this place’ etc. Google still counts on us, the common people, to improve all the time. For this reason, I maintain that we could deduct (really) helpful tips, but need to take into account that they will be ± true for about 95%.

@abermans @Kurt2day @StevenBerlin

Ich denke, jeder hat ein bisschen Recht und Unrecht.
Mir ist zum Beispiel aufgefallen, dass uns die eigenen Videos und Bilder in den bevorzugten Plätzen gezeigt werden, für andere aber nicht.
Andererseits sehe ich von bevorzugten LG uralte Bilder auf dem ersten Platz.
Ein anderes Beispiel: Neulinge werden mit ihren Bildern gefördert, um einen Anreiz zu schaffen.
Des Weiteren haben auch die Firmen Einfluss darauf, was wo gezeigt wird.
Es spielen so viele Faktoren eine Rolle.

Hallo Annaelisa. What do you mean with “haben auch die Firmen Einfluss darauf, was wo gezeigt wird.”. Do you have proof of this statement or is it a general feeling of the GBPs that you have seen at a very specific moment and a very specific place ? There are indeed many factors that play a role. I’m sure that, very soon, we will see specific pictures when we search for ‘coffee’ at 8 AM vs ‘coffee’ at 4 PM. In the morning, an image with a cup of coffee and a croissant would be more relevant. In the afternoon, it could show a cup of coffee with a piece of cake. Schönen Abend.

Ich habe keine Beweise, sondern es sind nur Feststellungen, die ich gemacht habe. Große Firmen mit vielen Filialen führen ihre Konten alleine. Als Beispiel: Eine Filiale war aufgrund eines Schadens und Renovierung länger geschlossen. Nach Fertigstellung kündigte die Filiale mit Plakaten die Eröffnung an und öffnete. Auf Google Maps blieb sie weiterhin als geschlossen bestehen und ließ sich weder durch die Filiale noch durch Kunden ändern. Erst als der zuständige Mitarbeiter in der Zentrale endlich reagierte und Google Maps aktualisierte, erfolgte die Änderung.
@Kurt2day

@Annaelisa When a profile is managed by a person (= an account) , it’s up to that person to show accurate information on the profile. When you make an edit on a profile, it sends a message to the account that manages the profile. That person can choose to accept or not accept the suggestion. When Google sees that the account is still active, Google prefers to trust the account and not the person who made the edit. They do that in order to prevent spammers and bad actors and even competitors. When a business closes for a certain time, they are supposed to put a post on their profile with that information.

Vollkommen korrekt :wink: @Kurt2day