About 3 weeks ago, I shared my research into Maps upload and feature statistics. Using my media upload pattern and featuring in (top 20) of a locations and tracking it about a month as I noticed significant drop after about a month of featuring.
I made some stratistical prediction, so now I went back to the same locations to see if I was right.
Starting from the end: I was.
The one-month pattern held, even in cities far from my first trip.
The reassuring 95% of keeping featured media that I reported last time was too early, though. Today 83% of my featured places are still featured.
My prediction came true
Last time I picked one group of places whose best photo was just about to turn 30 days old.
I assumed that they would probably lose 40 to 50% of their positions. They lost 57%.
I also checked whether my own new uploads (to same place) caused it, because a new photo can push an older one down. Without those places the loss is still 50%, so the upload age IS what matters.
It is the age of the photo, not the date on the calendar
Think of the date on a carton of milk. If Maps changed something on one particular day, all my places would have changed together. Instead, each place changed when its own photo reached about 30 days.
Places that passed the ~30 day mark between my two checks jumped from 7% to 58% losing ground. Places that were already past 30 days stayed about where they were.
It also happened everywhere, not only on my Wiltshire trip. Amsterdam went from 6% to 58% and Tokyo from 5% to 63%.
Meaning (currently) when maps is evaluting “refresh” needs, one month of featuring is a check point for keeping or replacing.
After 30 days it is a coin flip
Last time I wondered if the “oldest” photos had become safe (e.g. if they held past 30 days, they would keep featuring for long). They have not.
Between 30 and 60 days old, about half of my places lose ground, and the loss does not get better as the photo gets older. Only places with photos older than 60 days look calmer, at 17%, and even that number is slowly rising.
Not surprising: Busy places refreshes more frequently
A popular place gets new photos from many people, so there are more of them “competing” for the same top spots.
Again, using number of reviews as “popularity” index:
For places with a photo 30 to 59 days old, I lost position at 38% of the places with under 100 reviews, but at 81% of the places with 500 reviews or more. At those busy places 59% lost their spot in the top 20 completely.
The more (featured), the better
Naturally, Multiple (Two and more) featured photos at the same place, worked like a “safety” net.
Only 3 of my 103 places with two or more featured media items (by me) lost every feature, against 20% of places with just one.
The net does not stop the slide, but it keeps the place alive.
My new uploads, since those original batches, are also doing fine.
About 94% of the newer photos that were featured on 8 October still are.
Videos, which started slower than photos, have caught up: 58% of my videos are now featured, against 53% of photos.
I also said last time that views seem to take about two-three days to start showing up. That is still roughly true, but my age estimates this time are too rough to prove it, so I would not quote the exact number.
Finally, I still cannot say whether photos older than 60 days are “safer” (e.g. would take longer before being replaced), or just the survivors.
Beyond understanding, what it means
If you really want to maximize your impact and have time for strategy:
For popular places, treat 30 days as a “Cut off”, and try to keep a second great media there (Revisit or upload later).
For quiet places relax, because a feature there tends to slide down instead of disappearing.
This is my own reading of one contributor’s data, so please treat it as a hint and not a rule. Have you seen the same drop at around a month on your own photos? I would love to compare.
Earlier posts in the series: my million-view photos, still popular?, 1,106 places later.
Most important: Keep Contributing!
Sam
Tagging data hungry LGs
@tony_b @TerryPG @MortenCopenhagen @Annaelisa @StevenBerlin @Kurt2day @PrasadVR @WilfriedB



