Testing 3 types of Maps videos #TipsForBetterMapsVideos

Here is an interesting comparison of videos I took last night in Copenhagen. It was a beautiful summer evening with very soft light as the sun was setting (Golden Hour).

To make the 3 videos comparable I took them in short succession if the same restaurant called Mamarosa in the main pedestrian street.

In this reply @AdrianLunsong recommended to use Cinematic Pan to create stunning Maps videos.

So I wanted to test the Cinematic Pan. For comparison I also added a regular slowmotion video and a timelapse video.

I wanted to let the photo selection AI select which one (if any) would be featured at the very busy restaurant. It has close to 8000 reviews on Maps.

Here are the 3 videos

Cinematic Pan:

Standard Slowmotion:

Timelapse:

I edited the videos to increase Brightness and Dark spots to compensate for my pixel phones flat colors and low contrast. I also added some (probably annoying) music. And I uploaded them together.

Poll

Please view the 3 very short videos above and share which one of the 3 you think deserves to be featured at the restaurant.

  • Cinematic Pan
  • Normal Slowmotion
  • Timelapse
0 voters

Feel free to share why you think so in a reply below for an interesting discussion.

Actually, I already know that one video got featured. But I don’t have and view metrics yet. Here is the result.

The Timelapse video got featured at the restaurant as #3.

Later I will share some view metrics.

I would love you to also share your best tips on better Maps videos using the hashtag #TipsForBetterMapsVideos

Cheers

Are we also meant to vote @MortenCopenhagen ? :grin: If so, I would indeed go for the panned one.

I’m still editing this topic. I was considering to add a poll. Now I will. Hang on.

Dear @MortenCopenhagen , interesting analysis, if you want us to vote to know which one we think AI will pick, i ll go with 3rd option which is timelapse because the complete restaurant is visible in that one without much interruption

Hi there! I voted for nr 3,as in this video I can say if the restaurant is getting busier or how crowded the area is. Especially when I would like to sit outside during the sunny day. :slightly_smiling_face:

@MortenCopenhagen Bapak, bapak nih sangat jitu lo bapak . Titik suka malu sama bapak . Semangatnya luar biasa dan kali menerangkan satu trik dan tips itu mudah dipahami. Nyatanya lo Titik bisa di ajarin menempatkan maps setiap mau aplod artikel. Terima kaish lo bapak ilmunya. Dan sekarang membuat video. Titik tertantang ingin bisa lo bapak . Nanti Titik coba ya bapak . Kalau sudha agak enakan. O ya bapak sekalian bertanya nih. Beberapa waktu lalu bapak kan ke mall ya, karena mall belum buka jadi belum bisa mengedit informasi buka dan tutup tokonya . Nah yang mau Titik tau kalau mau mengedit tempat usaha orang begitu izin/permisinya bagaimana ya bapak? Mohon di ajarin bapak Titik suka sungkan soalnya. Xixixi maapin :folded_hands:t2::folded_hands:t2::folded_hands:t2:

Hi @TitikMariati

I would be pleased to answer your questions about editing the grand opening date and business hours. However not in this discussion which is about videos.

Feel free to ask the questions is a separate or related post.

Not mixing topics will make it much easier for others to search and find the information they need.

@MortenCopenhagen oh baik Bapak maafkan Titik . Siyap laksanakan. :folded_hands:t2::folded_hands:t2::folded_hands:t2::ok_hand:t3::ok_hand:t3:

@TerryPG @AdrianLunsong,
@AZ_2021, @tony_b maybe you would like to comment on this?

Also, @Rednewt74
@DshottDennis
@TravellerG
@MasaWithMaps
@AdamGT
@jayasimha78
might want to see this because you participated in video discussions earlier.

Mir gefällt das erste Video am besten, weil es mehr Eindrßcke vom Restaurant bietet. Nummer zwei ist mir zu langweilig.
Nummer drei gefällt mir auch sehr gut, weil alles in Bewegung ist. @MortenCopenhagen

Ich hätte die erste Aufnahme allerdings von der Seite angefangen, um zum Eingang des Restaurants mit Namen zu schwenken.

Great point. But I’m not yet fully familiar with the Cinematic Pan. There was an arrow shown in my camera. It pointed to the right and I was not able to test how to move in the opersite direction.

Hi @MortenCopenhagen, this is a really fun experiment. I completely agree with the AI picking the timelapse. It gives a much steadier and clearer view of the whole restaurant and shows the actual vibe of the crowd without the camera moving around too much. Makes total sense why the system preferred it for the place page. Thanks for sharing this test!

I loved the cinematic pan video @MortenCopenhagen It gives more details about the place as compared to the other two

Main content is restorant which is very nicely exicuted in 3rd one.

Hello @MortenCopenhagen, I liked the Cinematic Pan because it gives a wide and clear view of the storefront with a smooth left-to-right movement. It feels more like watching a real video.

Is it not a real real video? Just joking. I hope you are enjoying life.

:sweat_smile:Haha, good one! I know, it is a real video. I meant it feels more natural.

I agree. And it looks more interesting hence drawing in the viewers attention.

I don’t know enough about videos to know what those different names mean (yes, I know I could ask AI), but only the first one is “real”. When I pull out my phone and tap Camera, I either take a photo, or switch it to video. I’ve never tried to change any settings to alter what the video output would look like. I wouldn’t feel comfortable voting for #2 or #3, but I see you’ve already told us what the algorithm chose.

@MortenCopenhagen Interesting test! And fun too! However, because one of the videos is in landscape, for me, it’s not a true comparison. Also, it would be good to keep the length of all three clips the same.

I picked the timelapse as the video I think Maps would most likely feature because from a visual perspective, it feels like it’s showing more due to the landscape orientation.

For a portrait orientation, my preference is still for the cinematic Pan.

Side note: I initially thought that your slow motion shot is using the slow-mo mode but it’s actually still the cinematic Pan mode minus the panning movement. For those wondering, there is a slow-mo mode in Android and iOS phones but the output video is at regular speed with a middle portion slowed down, so it creates a cool effect of normal-slow-normal speed in the movement. And you can adjust the start and end points of the slowed section. Usually, this mode is great for sports or fast actions (e.g. a skateboarder doing a trick with their skateboard) where you want to slow down the video at a pivotal moment.

And just to add a bit more on the different video styles, I think that it highly depends on the subject that you’re taking and what you’re trying to show.

Still (the phone is held in the same position with no movements):

  • best for landscape orientation that can capture more of the subject. Switch to ultra wide lens, if needed and/or available. Example: exterior of buildings (use the same principle when capturing store front photos)
  • suitable for portrait orientation if the subject is tall and narrow. Example: a statue/monument
  • basically, you are trying to fit everything into your camera’s view

Panning (moving left-to-right or vice versa):

  • works in landscape or portrait orientation; usually when the subject is too big for the camera’s view and you have to pan to capture everything. Again, ultra wide lens will come in handy
  • great for capturing an indoor space and showing the vibe

Tilting (moving bottom-to-top or vice versa):

  • similar to panning but best for indoors where the building has a high and ornate ceiling that you’re trying to showcase
  • can also be used as a slow-reveal shot e.g. the video will show the sky/ground before tilting to reveal the subject. Timing is critical, you don’t want a video that spends too long showing the sky/ground before revealing the main focus

Cinematic + Still/Panning/Tilting (the video is slowed down):

  • you can switch to Pan mode (Android) and do a still/panning/tilting shot.
  • for panning/tilting, timing is critical because you don’t want to move too slowly otherwise it gets boring (unless the subject has a lot of interesting details that is worth moving slow to observe carefully).
  • my thought process on the speed is based on this simple notion: imagine yourself scanning a room (indoors) from one corner to another, and you’re trying to find a friend sitting at a table (i.e. you’re looking at the faces as you scan the room). If it took you 6 seconds to scan the room, then in your cinematic pan video, you would want to move your camera in 3 seconds, pointing from one corner to the other, such that the output video is 6 seconds long. The objective, is to create that natural speed of looking around but the ‘reality in the video’ is slowed down. I hope that makes sense!!

Timelapse (sped up video; camera is still/panning):

  • best for showing long movements whilst keeping your video short. Examples: a look-out point with a sunrise/sunset, bridges (people/traffic crossing the bridge), canals (boats moving along the waterways).
  • some folks with advance gadgets also add panning to the their timelapse which can result in a pretty cool video.

Hyperlapse (sped up video but camera is moving):

  • great to show the 360 exterior of a building.
  • it’s a bit tricky to do but doable. Just put your phone on Timelapse but you do a walk around the building whilst always maintaining the building the center of the shot. It’s tricky because it’s very easy, whilst walking, for the building to move out from the center. Fancy 360 cameras do this better because their software allows you to track an object.

For me, the beauty of the cinematic pan is that I can spend less time taking the video (because I’m moving my camera quite quickly) whilst getting a slowed down and smooth (motion wise i.e. less shakes) shot. This is perfect when I want to be discrete when I’m taking my video of a cafe/restaurant (or any indoor place).

Just another tip: the ultra wide lens for photos is usually fine but for videos, the quality isn’t very good. The sensor is usually poorer so you’ll see noise (if it’s low light) or artifacts.

And lastly, this is my most viewed video on Google Maps; it is a view of the Grand Palace in Bangkok, Thailand. It’s a cinematic pan+tilt in landscape. It’s not perfect as I should have trimmed 2 seconds off from the start (too much lily) but it’s a nice reveal and pan of the place. If I remember correctly, I also went from a low to high sweep (crouching to get close to the lily pads and then standing up). It’s managed to garner 6,600,404 views so far so please feel free to add to the view counts! :rofl:

https://maps.app.goo.gl/mgX1AAQdBf5pXNxC6