Need Help: Stop Spamming in My City(Ahmedabad)

In our city most of the businesses doing spam activity in Google My Business. In each industry they are manipulating Google Maps result by adding spam keywords in map. They are mainly adding lots of keywords in business name.

You can check below screen shot or check out results by searching these terms - “SEO company in Ahmedabad” or “Astrologer in Ahmedabad” or “ss pipe in ahmedabad”

What I tried to stop spamming in Google Map.

1. Suggest & Edit

=> I started suggest & Edit spam businesses, For the few days Google update businesses in instant basis. But after few days Google stop accepting my request because may Google think single user sending too much request. But the issue of Suggest & Edit was If I correct business name(Remove Keywords from Business Name) within few days the owners add keywords again.

2. Business Redressal Complaint Form

=> Then I move ahead with this form, I submitted more than 500 listing and many of them got suspended!! But After Covid 19 pandemic they don’t take down any spam business. I think Google My Business form built for fraudulent activity. So they don’t remove any of them.

What your thaought on this. Is there any way to stop spamming in Google My Business??

8 Likes

Hi @ahmedabad007

Thanks for all your efforts to clean the map. :pray:

Just adding “in Ahmedabad” is proabably not sufficient to have Google step in. In the rules there is one exception that allow chain stores to add the city name to their names. But adding keywords repeating or specifying further the category is never ok.

The screenshot you added is not readable on my end. It would be better if you mentioned one or maybe two examples of keyword spamming and mention when you used the redressal form on them.

Due to COVID-19 there might still be some delay in getting things cleaned up.

Did you use the Redressal form on just a single very clear issue just to be sure it is not working?

All the best

Morten

2 Likes

I’ve requested a Googler read this post @ahmedabad007 they may or may not respond but they will read it.

Paul

3 Likes

@ahmedabad007

In cases where the business revert your justified and approved removal of keywords you can raise this in the Maps support forum.

Hit the Community tap at the top and make a post. You need to attach

A screenshot of the email / approval for fixing the problem in the first place. Make sure the servers had time to sync before you post about it.

Cheers

Morten

2 Likes

Thanks for the quick response!

Here you can find the screenshot of the first-page result >> https://ibb.co/GHkkMYn

I can’t believe that 20 out of 2 business names didn’t have keywords stuffing in a business name. Also, most of the businesses use keywords as a business name like “SEO Company” or “Best SEO Company in Ahmedabad” or “SEO Company Ahmedabad”.

Also, Business Redressal Complaint Form mentions this line in the header section >> If you simply need to correct an incorrect business name, phone number, or URL, do not use this form.

That means they will not take any action on my requests. I feel I wasted my time. and this is not for the single terms or category or location. Most of the Google listings are spam-filled up with spam business names, target single addresses with multiple locations & more.

There is ZERO hope for those businesses who are following Google My Business Guidelines.

1 Like

Hi @ahmedabad007 ,

Thanks for reaching out to us! You have followed the right procedures indeed. Since you need further assistance, you can share a list of links you want us to re-assess and we will be glad to share them with the relevant team. As you are talking about many businesses, I suggest you make a document or a spreadsheet and share it with us here. Thanks.

2 Likes

It’s very time consuming process, But I prepared list of businesses who revert changes within few hrs or days.

You can find the excel file here >> https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1MRiKUZ-HeFc1RDSgvzsnbos23brlcdFT/edit?usp=sharing&ouid=112892134673369340875&rtpof=true&sd=true

Let’s see will Google going to take strict action against these spam business listing. These listings are cancer. They ranking on #1 page and literally ruining user experience.

If this thing will going on then everyone start doing spam and user will lost trust from Google.

2 Likes

@Giu_DiB

Did you forward this list to any authorized person. Or not going to take action on it?

1 Like

Hi @ahmedabad007 ,

The list you shared has been forwarded to the relevant team for further investigation. Thanks for taking the time to pull this data out, it is much appreciated.

As we are talking about dozen of profiles to be verified, keep in mind that it might take some time. Thanks for your patience!

1 Like

@Giu_DiB

If Google My Business team take strict action against these spam map, I could share more list with you. Because there are thousands of spam map published and manipulating local search results.

  • Will you forward this list too??
  • Should I share it here or I have to create new post for it?
1 Like

Hi @ahmedabad007 ,

Thanks for tagging me. If you have another list, you can share it with us here and we will be glad to forward it to the relevant team for review as we did with the previous one.

Have a nice day!

@Giu_DiB

Waited for more than 10 Days…

Couldn’t find and any single action against spam businesses. Zero hope so far…

Hi @ahmedabad007 ,

As I mentioned earlier, since you reported a few dozens of profiles, the verification process might take some time. Thanks again for your patience.

1 Like

It’s not about they need some time, They already take too many days!!!

@Giu_DiB

Now It’s more than 24 days gone still there is no single action taken against these spam businesses !!

I think there is no one person available at Google My Business Spam Department.

If I want to advertise my business. Google Provides instant CALL, CHAT, SCREEN SHARING, EMAIL support.

I think Google does not want to remove spam businesses because once the fake listings are removed the real businesses will rank on the #1 page and they will stop paid ads.

I hope, In the future, Someone from Google leaked these scam documents, like FACEBOOK PAPERS(https://cutt.ly/0YMt4Np) and the headlines will be, HOW GOOGLE FALSELY MAKING MONEY BY NOT REMOVING SPAM BUSINESSES AND INDIRECTLY FORCED USER FOR PAID ADS.

Hello @ahmedabad007 ,

The businesses you reported have been reviewed and the necessary actions were taken. Keep in mind that it could take some time for the changes to be visible publicly.

Have a nice day.

@Giu_DiB

Really !!

JOKE OF THE YEAR!!

Just 5-6 Businesses just removed spam keywords from the business name. The remaining businesses(more than 95 businesses) even added more keywords in business name in the last 2 days.

And now you come with answer that the businesses are reported and take some time for the changes to be visible publicly.

Hi @ahmedabad007 ,

I understand that you want to improve Maps with your contribution and that’s much appreciated. I also wanted to remind you that as Local Guides we should value the Maps accuracy as much as the Local Guides Program Terms and Conditions and The 5 cores values of Connect.

As your last comments and your tone don’t comply with them, I suggest you read the links I just shared with you, in order to avoid disciplinary actions towards your Local Guide’s profile. Thanks.