Error shadow banning?

Hey all,

I’m new to the Connect community but very active on Google Maps. I’m writing to see if there are any new solutions to this…

I spend a significant amount of time updating Google Maps and I do my best to add high quality photos + videos + reviews of places that I visit. Recently, I noticed that nearly half of my reviews are not showing. I emailed Google and they just kept sending me automated messages.

People might say, ‘your reviews violate policies…’ but how can that be? For example, it doesn’t matter what I write, my review doesn’t consistently show up. I’ve written both very simple reviews and very detailed ones - neither show up. Like today I went to a restaurant and posted a review, and it doesn’t show up publicly. However, my pictures do. It also seems that when I post reviews with pictures - they especially don’t show up. If I go back and edit an old review that is not publicly displaying, sometimes when I republish it, it will start showing up. So it is very inconsistent. I think it is a bug in their algorithm or perhaps my account is in a weird review state.

There has to be some way to speak with Google about this right? I feel like my account might be incorrectly blocking things or something. If not, why should I continue to contribute to Google Maps? There’s no point in me adding to Google Maps if my reviews don’t show publicly… can someone help with this?

2 Likes

Hi @BackpackingAndy

Welcome to the community.

Since this is your first post, you can also check Help Desk where you can find things to do here on Connect. You can also introduce yourself in the monthly topic.

As I saw at a glance, you’re doing well on Google Maps, so the problem shouldn’t be related to your account and this is not an account shadow ban. Hidden reviews are a common issue after the updates of spam filter. Emailing different teams in this regard is not the best way. Instead, when we’re sure our reviews don’t violate the policies, we can always ask for a check by filling out this form as prepared in the related announcement.

Note that after filling the form it may take several weeks to be checked and they fix the problem. And even after that we may face the same problem again after a while. This happened to me several times and every time I filled out the form. The AI has still lots of things to learn and our contributions are also part of this learning process.

3 Likes

This is super helpful! Mersi!

1 Like