Bug found in Adding place : Google Maps

There is an issue noted in Gmap while adding places, this probably can be a bug according to me.

Issue: While adding a missing place in Google maps, if try to add mobile number with that place, the place update will be instantly rejected by Google maps. The same place if try to add without mobile number it will get approved. I have noted this issue several times.

I have tried to add a new place in Google maps as shown in the image banner, “Kaveri Stores” with info such as mobile number, opened date, timings, when I, submitted this along with a couple of photos, it got rejected initially then I contacted a known local guide and suggested me to add it without mobile number, I tried to add the same place in 10 minutes without phone number and it got approved instantly. The same worked while adding two more places like this.

Why it is important?

Basically it pulls back local guide contributors to provide valid information such as mobile number which is the main thing for a business inquiry. I have seen very rarely people add missing information such as mobile number, email address after the place is created in my area, and community.

30 Likes

Sorry to correct you, @Sanjay_viswa , but email address is not something that you can add / edit in Google Maps.

Regarding the mobile number, what the help page Suggest edits to a place or flag it for removal says is: Use the primary phone number.

A mobile number do not guarantee a fixed location, so this may be the reason for an edit to be rejected at first

6 Likes

@Sanjay_viswa did you already try to add the phone number to the place you now added to the map (using “Suggest an edit”)?

As @ErmesT suggested: a mobile number might not be considered a “valid main phone number” by the algorithms checking your submission - which then probably leads to the entire submission to be rejected. That is just the way it works (although in my own experience quite a lot of new, small businesses do not invest in a land line anymore and therefore indeed have a mobile number as their main number). It could certainly explain why your submission was approved when not including the number.

So, my suggestion: try to create the place without the phone number, and once the place is on the map, try adding the main phone number (a land line if there is one, a mobile number is there is none).

3 Likes

Hello @Sanjay_viswa

That may not be a bug but deliberate change after a lot of unpleasant news about the phone number scams.

In India, many persons got fleeced after dialling the number visible in the app without any due diligence.

And, the subsequent clampdown on that may be the reason for the cheaters to adopt a new trick through Maps, to mislead the gullible clients.

1 Like

Hi @Sanjay_viswa and @JanVanHaver

In my experience a mobile phone number is OK if there is also a website or Facebook page mentioning the mobile number.

But it could easily be different in different regions.

Cheers

2 Likes

@Sanjay_viswa We were just discussing this issue at some lengths yesterday in chat. At least a few members don’t seem to be able to add phone numbers in India.

Some issues about harder to get approval when submitting with phone numbers.

And another about their interface does not allow to add phone number when creating a place. The below screenshot says “Add hours,website etc etc” but no phone numbers vs the usual "Add phone, hours, website… ". I have asked them to try to clear cache and try again. Will update when I hear more on this from them.

Below is a screenshot from their phone add place page before clearing cache.

4 Likes

I also find this same issue.

I used to have option for adding mobile number when adding new place.

I can’t find it now.

I am using latest version and also tried clearing cache

1 Like

@StephenAbraham @C_T @JanVanHaver Thanks for finding time to look into this issue. Yes, I realized where i went wrong. Thanks again.

6 Likes

No option to add phone number while adding a new place, some LGs have this issue in India, any solution for this?

Also if we are trying to add the phone number by editing, it’s not getting approved, why?

Hi all,

I found that there is no option to add phone number while adding a new place, some LGs have this issue in India, any solution for this?

Also if we are trying to add the phone number by editing, it’s not getting approved, why?

1 Like

Hello @arungeorge

Please create the POI without a phone number.

Later on, request the business owner to claim the place and update the number through Google My Business.

1 Like

My question is some LGs have the feature to add phone number while others don’t have this option, why is it like that

1 Like

Hi @arungeorge thank you for reaching out.

This normally happens if a lot of scams have been reported abusing the system on the same location, city or country, to protect or avoid this from happening, the Google team has that option to turn off that feature. As @C_T mentioned, only the business owner can do that from his or her own business account, and only if the business has been claimed trough Google My Business on Google Maps.

If some individuals are able to access this feature it meas this has been locked for some local guides in specific cities were it has been reported, I remember someone mentioned this in the passed few weeks.

1 Like

Hi @arungeorge ,

Thanks for reaching out to community! : ]

Please be noted that you may check as @Raphael-Mahumane kindly suggested (for which would be accepted as Solution also for providing the information).

For keeping the subject align, I have also relocated the current post to another one, kindly shared by @Sanjay_viswa , Bug found in Adding place : Google Maps.

From time to time, your edits may not be applied as we reserve the right to disable user generated contributions for individual business profiles and business categories to prevent abuse.

2 Likes

Still, not able to add my mobile number to my location as I am the owner