Bad Google Maps Data Keeps Getting Recreated / Reloaded

In the past I have submitted Google Maps updates to remove an non-existent location which eventually was reflected on the live public Google Map, but then after an unknown amount of time the bogus location would reappear. Can anyone with a personal connection to Google Maps employed sources help correct this, below is one specific example but as a universal rule for Goole Maps to incorporate in the future - if Google Maps accepts a Local Guide update to the map that invalidates data from one of thousands of data sources Google Maps scrapes for info, then Google Maps systems need to track that and prevent future data loads from recreating the same garbage data from the same or similar data load sources that created the garbage data a Local Guide already corrected.

Here is the location link to a representative address -
324 Horton Ave, San Diego, CA 92101

The location claims to be “U.S. Army Recruiting Center - University Branch Office”
visible on Maps at
https://www.google.com/maps/place//@32.7316929,-117.1679908,20.46z?entry=ttu

Clicking on the location label brings up the left frame Maps location info:

  • 324 Horton Ave does not exist as an address anywhere in the greater San Diego county area in any zip code, verifiable at the County Recorder office GIS website
  • the map pin location for the non-existent 324 Horton Ave address is displayed on Google Maps in the 2500 block of Horton Ave (undeniably wrong)
  • the map pin location is also on an empty lot per Street View and real life
  • the website that Google Maps assocaites to the place/location is a dead URL - html 404 error URL not found on this server
  • yet Google Maps recreates this bogus location on the rare occassion Suggest an Edit updates submitted are actually Accepted

How can Google Maps automated data scrapes even allow such an obvious example of bad data with flaws on 3 or more data fields become official Maps data in this alleged age of artificial intelligence (obviously marketing hype) but easy for humans to code automated data quality checks into data scraping data input verification checks before adding locations into Maps?

The Maps Local Guides updates Suggest an Edit submissions don’t allow enough detail to categorize what the problem is, and when a submitted edit is Not Accepted by auto-processed or human-processed review of the submitted edit occurs, there is no feedback/justification to the Local Guide about why the edit wasn’t accepted.

5 Likes

@socalmappinginfo

Is this the pin you are referring to:

https://maps.app.goo.gl/aeRV55eWt2bY47bF6 ?

Cheers

Morten

2 Likes

Yes, that is the correct pin - with the 324 Horton Ave address placed on an empty parcel in the 2500 block of Horton Ave, and the website linked to a non-existent URL - hope you can help remove this ongoing!

1 Like

Hi @socalmappinginfo

Thanks for your reply.

It would be very helpful if you would use the tagging tool when replying to someone here on Connect. Type @ followed by the username. Type slowly. Then we get an e-mail notification and you are more likely to get a prompt reply. Just hitting Reply does not ensure we get notified by email.

The repeated reappearances of this pin are not due to the scraping of data. There is not “Claim this business” link to be found. This means that someone already claimed and verified their ownership of the business to Google Maps. When this is done successfully the “owners” get more editing power. And they can create a spreadsheet with the data from several pins. This spreadsheet can then be uploaded repeatedly to avoid edits and removals.

To remove it you can suggest it closed permanently. Or as “Does not exist here”. Trus you have tried this already. Next step would be to remove it as spam.

I just tried that to no avail:

Most likely because the place is claimed and verified. It had photos, and one of them shows a sign. And there ere 7 reviews.

The next step will be to seek help on this in the Maps support forum.

Hit the Community tab at the top and make a post. You need to better document this.

Include this link: https://maps.app.goo.gl/Gqj8PiJKjezPxAce8 to show that the office is nowhere to be found here, and explain that the pin is located in the street. The website https://us-army-recruiting-center-university.business.site/?utm_source=gmb&utm_medium=referral is dead and not populated. You could also add that legit offices use this website: https://www.goarmy.com/ and they use the correct category Military Recruitment office.

You might also be lucky that @InaS will escalate this for you.

Cheers
Morten

2 Likes