A badge without any contribution? It appears the Connect site is generous in its offerings.

Whenever I go through the Connect profile of a person, I also look for the posts marked as solutions.

Amazingly, some users display the badge of “New solutionist.” However, no content appears under the heading Solutions.
Nevertheless, these aren’t old cases from the previous version of Connect.

It isn’t possible to conceal or delete any post. However, sometimes the solution is undone. Nevertheless, the badge remains.

I find that’s the way the Connect site makes the users happy. Once a user receives a badge, that remains forever even though the underlying posts vanish for whatever reasons!

19 Likes

Hi @C_T

It sure sounds strange. I have never noticed this issue. Rather the opposite. After earning a solution the counter does not increase. So, I suspect that solutions that later are merged into other discussions are actually subtracted from count of solutions.

I just counted af found the following on my profile: The page with solutions lists 49 solutions and the counter is stuck at 22 (for months is has been 20-21).

Best regards

1 Like

Hi @C_T thank you for reaching out.

I have not experienced that my self, but I hope to know what is really happening to that badge. First, can you please confirm if this is an existing local guide profile with actual posts or just a profile with badges and no content created under it.

The Badge you are talking about is it something like the one appearing on the screen short bellow, but without details under the badge :

1 Like

Hello @MortenCopenhagen

That’s a bizarre way to display the statistics. Although there are counts of “Total Solutions Marked Accepted” (by you) and “Total Solutions Unmarked Accepted” (by you) the stats page does not display the count of your answers accepted as solutions. We need to count that by going through the “Solutions” tab.

1 Like

Yes @Raphael-Mahumane . One such profile is there in today’s “How-to’s” section. I came across many such profiles. However, I do not wish t mention any specific one to protect the privacy.

1 Like

Hi @MortenCopenhagen thank you for mentioning your issue, regarding total number of solution count being stuck, can you please create a separate post about it so that it can be investigated, if there is something wrong about it, as it might happen that it is affecting more local guides but since we never notice we will never know. Cheers!

2 Likes

OMG @C_T

Thanks for explaining that

Total Solutions Marked Accepted
Total Solutions Unmarked Accepted

are referring to how many times I have marked someone else’s replies as a solution.

I will consider proposing the following improvements to prevent others from making the same “stupid” mistake:

Total Solutions Received

Total Solutions Given

Would you support this in the Ide Exchange?

Thanks again

2 Likes

Hi @Raphael-Mahumane

C_T straighten out my misunderstanding. See my reply suggesting a better wording in the stats.

So it was not stuck - I misunderstood the in-precise wording on the stats.

Cheers

1 Like

Certainly @MortenCopenhagen

The current wording is confusing & needs to be refined.

1 Like

Hi @MortenCopenhagen no problem, I am glad you managed to see it early.

Please vote for this idea to improve the wording discussed in this thread:

Solution Stats

Cheers

1 Like

@C_T , @MortenCopenhagen

this is what I can see on my private statistic.

Where:

  • Total Solutions Authored is the number of solutions “counted” that I have
  • Total Solutions Marked Accepted is the number of solutions accepted by me
  • Total Solutions Unmarked Accepted is the number of solutions accepted by me

Being a Moderator I can accept and remove solutions also on others post that are not mine

Regarding badge and solutions, please remember that in Connect we see what I can see. If the solution, in the specific case, has been received on a board where we do not have access, we will not be able to see the post

5 Likes

Thanks for clearing things up for us, @ErmesT

The issue was that the line Total Solutions Authored is not visible for non-moderators.

As a consequence I have adjusted my proposal for better wording in the Idea Exchange.

Thanks again

4 Likes

Appreciate your clarification @ErmesT

I know, I do not have access to the SVTP board. I do not know any other board where I do not have access.

The case which I came across anew, does not have an SVTP badge.

Nevertheless, I have observed the same phenomenon even in case of a new writer badge too. Sometimes, a solo post by the user either gets marked as spam, or merged with some existing thread. Still the badge remains.

1 Like

The latest example is interesting, @C_T

In a previous case that I observed, the solution badge was removed after 24 hours (it was a Local Guide giving solutions to himself, and I removed all the solutions because not appropriate).

Regarding posts, my feeling is that a post is counted even if on a second step is merged.

Btw, I will have to verify this part

2 Likes

Hi, @C_T

In my experience, some times ago, I’ve recieved a notification that stated that a Moderator has flag my comment as a solution. When I checked it, yes, I’ve got the badge.

But soon after that, when I check the post which my comment has flagged as a solution, the moderator has untag and unflag my comment as solution. When I check my profile, the badge is gone. The solution tab in my profile is back empty.

The solution tab in local guides’ profile is public. It will show the comment that was flagged as solution.

1 Like

You still have the solutionist badge as well as the solution on your profile @iorikun301

2 Likes

The badge that I had now is different story, @C_T :smiling_face::smiling_face:

1 Like

Hello @iorikun301

The badge does not vanish even though a solution is unmarked. I am sharing a screen shot of one profile (hiding some of the details so as to protect the privacy).

2 Likes

@MortenCopenhagen

That you mention,

It’s shows in my private statics.

I give reply in your idea Solution Stats…

Check that.

3 Likes